12 Likes, all from moochers 
Nobody should get rewards from any Guild they arenât a part of, that flies in the face of competition.
First our resources get nerfed, now add ârevenue sharingâ? How about players work for their rewards and not get free stuff from others? I vote firmly NO to an in-game welfare system.
A novel idea to use excess guild and maintain balance. Has a ring of communism to it.
Personally I doubt this will be accepted as it means many players will essentially be âgetting something for nothingâ. Doubt this will sit well with the top contributors and it reduces the need for players to spend real cash. Developers do need to make a living after all.
Yeah there is a fine balance between keeping people interested and giving too much away. Would require careful tuning.
Thatâs deeply disrepectful - but you will never have that ounce of empathy needed to understand why.
I do agree with you though, I do not like the global reward idea either.
Possible mythic tasks surely wonât be available in the next 5-6 weeks (thatâs when the small patch should hit)
It is not ideal but you need to put it into perspective. It is extremely unlikely that the devs will revert to anything like the old guild resource system and the above suggestion is one way to increase the resources gained (by some moderate factor) and provides something for people to work towards all while maintaining the guild updates philosophy.
Unless actual PvP is introduced the only competition that exists is trophy count anyway.
Donât get butthurt dude. Not only did you manage to be even more disrespectful than I was, but you wrongly assume Iâm lacking a piece of being human.
I hope you, and everyone else, realizes that this is an online persona. The things I say and do should never really be taken too seriously.
If you truly want to devolve into personal attacks though, thatâs cool. What would your kids say though?
What everyone else realizes is that behind that online persona is a living person, and in your case, itâs one that chooses to be angry and disparaging to other real, living people, from the safety of your computer. Thatâs what gives other people here the impression that you lack empathy. Saying that youâre not being serious doesnât make your behavior acceptable, any more than acting this way on the internet rather than face-to-face does.
Would you rather we meet face-to-face? Iâm not sure if that is what you are aiming at.
And letâs not pretend the majority of people online donât have a different persona than in real life. Iâm sure you havenât confronted a single person in reality like you just did with me here, first reason would be having to leave the safety of mommaâs basement.
Other people doing something doesnât make it right. Your behavior is unacceptable regardless of the venue.
Then wipe your eyes and report me.
And my original point stands. Work for your own damn rewards and stop wishing for free stuff, especially from other players not in your Guild. Check your privilege 
Fine. You asked. Tired of you. Sue us for taking offense that you think high-leveled players and guild masters are âmoochersâ.
Sorry someone derailed the thread by being aggravating.
You got that completely backwards. You get points for effort though.
Itâs pointless even trying to talk to you. No more.
Awww, now you lose those effort points. 
The global task is just unrealistic. A reward for all guilds? Do you really think that devs are going to give so much ressources (RewardxNbPlayers)? Or else it will be one gold key for each playerâŚ
About the guild requirements, we increase our gold contribution to 400k: the goal is to have everyone that provide the same amount of golds. If you play more, you keep more.
And only 1200 seals for the moment.
In fact, I donât understand how you can ask for 1500 seals and ask only 300k golds. For doing that much seals, you need a lot of battles and so players âproduceâ a lot of golds. So 500k golds should be easy for someone doing the 1500 seals. No?
No.
Last week I got 1500 seals (by sunday, but I still did a lot of explores after), but I have only contributed about a 200K gold to the guild. Thatâs because I stopped PvPing and switched to purely explores once I reached tier 1 (+ a bit).
Not necessarily. You can get to 1500 without ever stepping a foot in PVP.
Plus you need to do about 3000 Gold a fight if you strictly did PvP to hit 500k by the time you get 1500 Seals.
300k sounds perfectly reasonable.