As a guild we are trying to figure out good and bad defenses based on win/loss ratio. But this week proved that this is not sufficient.
Because it does not account for eg people switching to a team where only three troops are on color. Or for teams that either outright win or outright lose.
Case in point. Due to dwarf week I switched to a three-on-color team on red day, giving me an easy five wins that scored about 8500. That is less than my normal 9000-9300, but more than the typical 7700 I would get for a 4/1 record.
I would like to see the average score people managed to get against my defense team, besides the win/loss ratio. I think that’s the most informative single stat that can be added. Ofcourse, if an entire log of those defenses including GW points scored can be provided (say through a similar ? interface as on the attack page), that would be awesome.