What your advice fails to realize.
And almost ironically since it was in reply to @Silchas here is.
People who play gems of war at that level are more often than not…self driven anyway. They aren’t in a top guild because they are required to be. They are in a top guild because their activity fits the style of those Requirements already.
I myself asked Silchas numerous times not to get burned out by the various things to do in the game. Unfortunately… The devs kept on keeping on. Maybe it’s their fault, maybe it’s his fault, maybe it’s no one’s fault… It’s not however… The managers fault who base their requirements off the game though. I mean come on. You’re literally blaming the middle man here. Lol
@Silchas will be the first to tell you, he would of quit the game months (if not years) before he finally did. If it weren’t for my guilds. (Which is the opposite of your argument I think.)