Deleted by OP
I’m really hesitant to vote here because casual pvp gold was recently nerfed. I’m not sure it’s a good idea to spell out what’s optimal in case more nerfs are in the pipeline.
I think ranked pvp is by far the worst of these three options, but it’s being completely reworked soon™.
I’m going to leave the thread open, but as a warning (to everyone involved), I’m getting a little cranky with all the flag metaposting going on here. Yes, it’s a right; yes, it can be taken away if abused; yes, we expect everyone here to use it responsibly. Please do not flag vindictively or in retribution. That is not what this system is for.