I have already informed my guild of my decision to quit. The chosen implementation of GW has ruined the game for me. I may play a little casually in PvE later on, but I will not join a GW-participating guild.
There are two fundamental problems with Gems of War: (1) The AI is borked (and everyone knows it), and (2) The RNG isn’t truly random, because a bad algorithm was chosen (there is graduate-level math behind what I say), and the devs refuse to change it. The abnormal repeating of gems in cascades, the streakiness of the Death Mark effect, and the streakiness of key drops are all explained by this one condition.
The implementation of the Guild Wars was plagued, IMHO, by a string of poor design choices all intended to cover up the two basic issues above, and to mislead players into thinking that the defenses in GW would be similar enough to human play to make the sum total feel like true head-to-head competition, which it most certainly is not. In particular, they knew the chosen scoring system would generate interminable arguments, and in so doing prevent the vast majority of players from thinking about the points made above. It is not, again IMHO, the most ethical way to conduct business in the gaming industry. When people spend money on a competitive game, they have a right to know what the rules are.
(In the interest of full disclosure, I have always been VIP 0. I have never had any issues with the VIP system in and of itself.)
Finally, the atmosphere in the game’s official forums is downright poisonous, I am not exaggerating when I say it is the worst I have seen in at least 20 years of online gaming. I can’t even count the number of people I would have long-since banned from these forums, had it been my call. I’m sure some of them will flame me here, at least until the devs lock or remove the thread, and they’ll be wasting their time, as I won’t be here to read it. I am convinced the direction forum regulars are lobbying the devs is not even close to the wishes of the player base as a whole. I have seen quite a few very good online games fail after falling into this trap.
So, for all the people who like what you’re getting, have fun with this. I’m not.