Yup. While both Xbox and PS are Consoles, our games are almost completely separate. Different players, guilds, etc. We have similarities, like we both have Daily Tasks, and before console caught up to PC/Mobile, when new troops would come out, they would come out for both consoles, etc.
But, the consoles do have sepetate “ecosystems”, we can’t play cross platform with each other at all. If I was a betting man, I would venture to guess that’s mostly Sony’s fault. With Xbox putting so much effort in cross play gaming with stuff like Rocket League and Fortnight, but Sony blocking that ability on their platform, I would assume that Sony is at least part of the reason why GoW doesn’t have that, at least between consoles.
As for as PC/Mobile, I believe that’s because we use different servers than them or something like that, so that makes cross play with them either impossible, or at least a huge pain to try and do. That could have something to do with Sony too, I’m not sure. The servers thing was just something I would told a few times.
Also, I brought up the idea of a companion app once, like what Rock Band 4, Dying Light, and GTA 5 have for their games. Basically, an app that can interact with the console game. I asked if there was a way to make something like that so we (console players) could at least collect tribute and mail while away from our console. They, more or less, told me they couldn’t do. In the sense they weren’t allowed, not that they couldn’t actually design something like that. So, there’s that.
Then, of course, there’s the redeem codes. Xbox said okay, Sony said no, so neither console gets them. As far as the 150 gem Dungeon pack is concerned, I don’t know why Sony has that but the rest of us don’t.
Basically, what I’m saying here is, yes, you’re right. There are 3 games of GoW. Xbox, PS4, PC/Mobile. And they’re all far from created equal. In my opinion, there’s the PC/Mobile “Elites” and then Xbox and PS4 have to fight each other for table scraps. Again, just my opinion.
