Geeze, I leave you guys alone for one day!
You chose the wrong day, now you have a novel to read
I skimmed it.
Itās a decent plan, and we considered a similar one with sliding requirements. We ultimately stayed with a static requirement because a sliding scale is much harder for members to check their progress on during the week (without using a spreadsheet) and thus more prone to confusion. Definitely not a deal breaker but it was enough of a hassle to make it a moot point for us; however, we have a much more intricate rank system than most guilds, so to each their own.
Iāve got my fingers crossed for you guys, though; it sounds like youāll make it work. Now hurry up and get in the top 30, will ya? We miss hanging out with you guys.
Though I should point out one obvious fatal flaw with your new system:
WHERE ARE THE GUILD POINTS FOR MEME POSTING?!
I know Iām just an intruder with no vote but @HKdirewolfās work is valuable and deserves to be rewarded!
I think @HKdirewolf has a meme waiting for you
Iāve been testing some numbers, trying to consider all types of player, hereās what I thought:
- 1 = 4 GP (no change)
- 1k Gold = 2 GP
- 2 Seals = 1 GP
A few examples of requirement that would work:
- 350 + 200k Gold +1,000 Seals (Trophy only)
- 100 + 700k Gold +1,000 Seals (Gold only)
- 150 + 475k Gold +1,500 Seals
- 200 + 425k Gold +1,300 Seals
- 250 + 400k Gold + 1,000 Seals
- 225 + 325k Gold + 1,500 Seals
- 250 + 275k Gold +1,500 Seals
- 250 + 325k Gold +1,300 Seals
I think we should see how
1 trophy = 4GP
5 seals = 3GP
2k gold = 3 GP
Goes and take this numbers if it doesnāt do good on the end of the week. Personaly I think people should be donating more gold so having it award 2GP for every 1K gold feels a bit to much. At the same time 5 seals = 3 GP enable a member to get 300GP for hitting 1500 seals instead of 250GP which would be earned with 2 seals = 1 GP ratio.
I may be a bit slow in picking this up, butā¦
Weāre saying the new requirement would be 1000 guild points AND you need to make 1000 seals AND 100 trophies. No?
If not, then we are saying 400GP from trophies, and 200GP from seals minimums. Thatās 600 GP. Then you need to come up with another 400 GP however you want. So that could be another 100 trophies and no gold. Thatās a lot less than weād talked about. Or, as I thought (maybe) Don was saying, do you have to do those minimums and ON TOP OF that get another 1000 GP? If so, then that makes more sense to me.
I do not favor banking, but thatās me.
Reqs are both. Basic requirements are 100 trophies 1000 seals 200k gold and 1000 guild points. All 4 need to be met. Every trophy a member earn above 100 from basic requirements awards 4 GP. Every 5 seals above 1000 from basic requirements awards 3 guild points.
Itās up to every individual to decide through which part will they earn 1000 GP, but everyone needs to do basic requirements and 1000 GP on top of that.
So itās a bit more then what we discussedo, definitely not less
I honestly didnāt understand eerything you said, but none of the options we presented are less than we talked about. Theyāre all more, and now Iām afraid theyāre more by a large margin, idk. 200 trophies + 300k gold + 1,500 seals wonāt cut it in this system.
All GPs are obtained only from contributions that are above the minimum for each resource. Everyone has to donate 100 trophies + 1k seals + 200k gold, and, on top of that, 1,000 GP more, and those go however you like, following the convertion rates.
You might wanna check the OP here, itās been edited and an overview of the system (only the values are not updated as of now, but it should give you an idea)
Need. A. Panadol.
I just want to get confirmation before I edit the OP. These are the numbers that we are testing this week, correct, @DonBoba?
And while I am asking and editing, would you like me to remove the Bank info from the OP? I think the guild is pretty unanimous against it. MM doesnāt want any slackers or any excuse for slacking!! Kudos to everybody for being vocal about that. I respect that alot.
Ok, everyone is against bank so remove it
And numbers are:
1 trophy = 4 GP
5 seals = 3 GP
1k gold = 2 GP
Those are finals until the end of the week
OP has been edited.
@MakoSipper If you have a link to the Spreadsheet, I would like to add it in the OP so that everybody can have easy access to it.
I refrained from disclosing the link here because some people might not want their contributions revealed to just anyone.
Fair enough.
Itās there on discord tho so thatās enough. I agree about privacy part
Will be on laptop soon to login to discord and overlook document.
@DonBoba a mention would have been nice
but no sweat, I am here now.