Guild Wars Reforged Feedback

Basta obsidius per bloccarle

If the setting was like the previous Guild War, a player can’t place more than 1 of each unit.

I think it might be harder there will probably be lots of red book defenses that will get filled first turn and can wreck you faster than the dragon and leave your whole team frozen if you get a turn

1 Like

Highly unlikely. Book defenses each require a very specific set of troops, which won’t be possible to set up due to region restrictions.

3 Likes

This week I have to thank the Guild Wars purchase issue (and the resulting forum bug report) for reminding me to set defenses, since there is still no in-game popup/notification.

:man_shrugging: :vulcan_salute:

8 Likes

There does not need to be reminders that the notifications about the GW beginning need to be more apparent.

I have passed it onto the team, but at the moment there is no further update.

2 Likes

I understand the practical reason for asking players to not constantly reiterate requests and will of course adhere to it, even though this is the kind of trivially easy to solve issue that could have been sorted right away as a win-win, thus reducing the large pile of pending QoL requests with minimum effort..

..so much so that the fact that it still hasn’t been implemented would suggest that no programmer has yet seen this QoL request in the list.

Looking forward either way.

:pray: :vulcan_salute:

3 Likes

2 posts were split to a new topic: Incorrect GW opponents displayed

I really like that. I guess the “Top Player” stuff might happen with patch 8.9 and the scoreboard, so no worries there for now. But I have already a note here: instead of Building 1-8 in the list, use the Building labels itself

So instead of Building 6, its Temple. And Building 8, is Maze. Or the other way around if you count from right to left. But thank you to give us at least an overview were our own people failed, as well as to see where the enemy guild failed.

Hopefully we still get an individual counter to see how our personal Defense Team did. Like in the old days. But the current overview is already helpful, even if we can’t pinpoint which players defense did work and which defenses got steamrolled.

4 Likes

@Jeto would you please describe the numbers of buildings? Is this correct?

2 Likes

It’s all nice and dandy, but what is that thing in a custom-size windowed mode? (And NO, I will not use full screen, I will not use any of the offered resolution options. My own custom size is the only way I roll.)

3 Likes

Hi Nagflar_dv,

We did the work up based on our uneven attack distribution yesterday. That is the correct layout.

3 Likes

We need to be able to see which guild members aren’t attacking. I get why scores are hidden but we absolutely have to know who isn’t participating.

8 Likes

In theory that is seemingly planned for 8.9 Guild Wars Reforged Feedback - #584 by Jeto but you a are of course right. We need to see if some people just have single day fallouts due to RL circumstances, or ride out every GW day and every Defense setup every month. And we need to see the individual score of guild members, to also see if they progress “normal” during GW, or sit 5x at the Gate while “participating and having won 5 fights”.

5 Likes

Playing against guilds that don’t e

ven exist and have no rating, all gate battles for everyone and 0 rating points for winning the day

How does number 3 ranked and 50k ranked guild that doesn’t even exist get paired together besides complete incompetence of the development team

1 Like

My wife’s guild 2 player guild and ranked 1,667 :rofl:

Bugs need to be in their own threads and not in feedback threads.

The missing building names and incorrect end of day result information has since been reported, from their existing threads.

For those who are into pvp, wouldn’t it be better if guild wars were every week? Seems as it is now the rankings move at a glacial rate. Doesn’t seem very exciting to me. I imagine of you’re in a guild that’s into guild wars you’d want to challenge that rank as often as possible.

Not in this current state. It needs a lot of adjustments and polish before it could even be talked about let alone considered.

3 Likes

For those who are into pvp, wouldn’t it be better if guild wars were every week? Seems as it is now the rankings move at a glacial rate. Doesn’t seem very exciting to me. I imagine of you’re in a guild that’s into guild wars you’d want to challenge that rank as often as possible.

No. Not everyone has the same schedule and the current Guild Wars is too punishing if you miss a day for completely normal and understandable reasons. Not only that but attack restrictions are ridiculous while defenses are near impossible to beat with some kingdoms. Although I understand the point of competition and a challenge, that must also be balanced. I do not feel like the current Guild Wars is balanced. That and there are too many bugs.

3 Likes