Deeds - Discussion and Critique

Dec. 14, 2019 First Writ AB Task

I’m not sure how to incorporate these writs since you can use them to make any color deed. Maybe I’ll just keep a running tally. :thinking:

12 Likes

Xbox says 100 writs to craft a deed, 1000 for an imperial. Absolutely not chasing those “rewards”.

Doing the math, if we get this task once every two weeks, we’ll be able to craft two and a half deeds over the course of a year, or one imperial deed in four years. Probably not even worth keeping tally off, maybe for the sake of completeness (and to document the disconnect between players and devs).

6 Likes

Older post, but a thing this particular quote made me think is:

“If we got different tasks daily we’d have a much larger representation of how random the data is, but some people would have ridiculous luck with purple deeds.”

Damned if you do, damned if you don’t.

Here are the current deed rewards:
Deeds of Color I: 4 deeds
Deeds of Color II: 6 deeds + 1 imperial
Deeds of Color III: 9 deeds + 2 imperial

If we use the devs own conversion of 1 imperial = 10 deeds, here is how writs would scale
Writing Writs I: 10 writs ( .1 deed)
Writing Writs II: 40 writs (.4 deed)
Writing Writs III: 80 writs (.8 deed)

These writ tasks are such garbage I’d rather not even have them. They just serve to dilute the pool.

6 Likes

Epic tasks remain an embarrassment. 100 writs ain’t worth anything like the task expense required.

Brown Epic Adventure Board Task

Dec. 16, 2019 | Day 105 since first Deeds in AB:


Without Epic Tasks

Non-Flash Offer Table

Deed Type Current Amt Total Amt Days Needed To Complete
Imperial 17 102 630
Blue 24 146 639
Green 38 146 404
Red 37 176 500
Yellow 28 176 660
Purple 22 176 840
Brown 24 176 770

With Flash Offer Table

Deed Type Current Amt Total Amt Days Needed To Complete Price [USD]
Purple 30 176 616 $17.00

With Epic Tasks

Non-Flash Offer Table

Deed Type Current Amt Total Amt Days Needed To Complete
Imperial 17 102 630
Blue 25 146 614
Green 39 146 394
Red 38 176 487
Yellow 29 176 638
Purple 23 176 804
Brown 25 176 740

With Flash Offer Table

Deed Type Current Amt Total Amt Days Needed To Complete Price [USD]
Purple 31 176 597 $17.00

NOTES:
These tables do not include the original freebie deeds given out by mail when deeds were introduced.
Epic Tasks provide 1 deed per color.


Writs

Writs from AB Only

Amt Color Deed Exchange Imperial Deed Exchange
10 0 0

Writs from AB and Tasks

Amt Color Deed Exchange Imperial Deed Exchange
189 1 0

NOTES:
These tables do not include the original freebie writs given out by mail as a gift.
Epic Tasks provide 179 writs.

8 Likes

Ultra-Rare Writ Adventure Board Task

Green Deed Purchase

Dec. 19, 2019 | Day 108 since first Deeds in AB:


Without Epic Tasks

Non-Flash Offer Table

Deed Type Current Amt Total Amt Days Needed To Complete
Imperial 17 102 648
Blue 24 146 657
Green 38 146 415
Red 37 176 514
Yellow 28 176 679
Purple 22 176 864
Brown 24 176 792

With Flash Offer Table

Deed Type Current Amt Total Amt Days Needed To Complete Price [USD]
Purple 30 176 634 $17.00
Green 40 146 395 $1.99

With Epic Tasks

Non-Flash Offer Table

Deed Type Current Amt Total Amt Days Needed To Complete
Imperial 17 102 648
Blue 25 146 631
Green 39 146 405
Red 38 176 501
Yellow 29 176 656
Purple 23 176 827
Brown 25 176 761

With Flash Offer Table

Deed Type Current Amt Total Amt Days Needed To Complete Price [USD]
Purple 31 176 614 $17.00
Green 41 146 385 $1.99

NOTES:
These tables do not include the original freebie deeds given out by mail when deeds were introduced.
Epic Tasks provide 1 deed per color.


Writs

Writs from AB Only

Amt Color Deed Exchange Imperial Deed Exchange
20 0 0

Writs from AB and Tasks

Amt Color Deed Exchange Imperial Deed Exchange
199 1 0

NOTES:
These tables do not include the original freebie writs given out by mail as a gift.
Epic Tasks provide 179 writs.

8 Likes

Dec. 23, 2019 | Day 112 since first Deeds in AB:


Without Epic Tasks

Non-Flash Offer Table

Deed Type Current Amt Total Amt Days Needed To Complete
Imperial 17 102 672
Blue 24 146 682
Green 38 146 431
Red 37 176 533
Yellow 28 176 704
Purple 22 176 896
Brown 24 176 822

With Flash Offer Table

Deed Type Current Amt Total Amt Days Needed To Complete Price [USD]
Purple 30 176 658 $17.00
Green 40 146 409 $1.99

With Epic Tasks

Non-Flash Offer Table

Deed Type Current Amt Total Amt Days Needed To Complete
Imperial 17 102 672
Blue 26 146 629
Green 40 146 409
Red 39 176 506
Yellow 30 176 658
Purple 24 176 822
Brown 26 176 759

With Flash Offer Table

Deed Type Current Amt Total Amt Days Needed To Complete Price [USD]
Purple 32 176 616 $17.00
Green 42 146 390 $1.99

NOTES:
These tables do not include the original freebie deeds given out by mail when deeds were introduced.
Epic Tasks provide 1 deed per color.


Writs

Writs from AB Only

Amt Color Deed Exchange Imperial Deed Exchange
20 0 0

Writs from AB and Tasks

Amt Color Deed Exchange Imperial Deed Exchange
378 3 0

NOTES:
These tables do not include the original freebie writs given out by mail as a gift.
Epic Tasks provide 179 writs.

3 Likes

Legendary Red Adventure Board Task

Legendary Blue Adventure Board Task

Dec. 24, 2019 | Day 113 since first Deeds in AB:


Without Epic Tasks

Non-Flash Offer Table

Deed Type Current Amt Total Amt Days Needed To Complete
Imperial 19 102 607
Blue 30 146 550
Green 38 146 435
Red 43 176 463
Yellow 28 176 711
Purple 22 176 904
Brown 24 176 829

With Flash Offer Table

Deed Type Current Amt Total Amt Days Needed To Complete Price [USD]
Purple 30 176 663 $17.00
Green 40 146 413 $1.99

With Epic Tasks

Non-Flash Offer Table

Deed Type Current Amt Total Amt Days Needed To Complete
Imperial 19 102 607
Blue 32 146 516
Green 40 146 413
Red 45 176 442
Yellow 30 176 663
Purple 24 176 829
Brown 26 176 765

With Flash Offer Table

Deed Type Current Amt Total Amt Days Needed To Complete Price [USD]
Purple 32 176 622 $17.00
Green 42 146 393 $1.99

NOTES:
These tables do not include the original freebie deeds given out by mail when deeds were introduced.
Epic Tasks provide 1 deed per color.


Writs

Writs from AB Only

Amt Color Deed Exchange Imperial Deed Exchange
20 0 0

Writs from AB and Tasks

Amt Color Deed Exchange Imperial Deed Exchange
378 3 0

NOTES:
These tables do not include the original freebie writs given out by mail as a gift.
Epic Tasks provide 179 writs.

6 Likes

Hm. That’s four posts in a row by you. Did Discourse lift the restriction on consecutive posts by a single author?

2 Likes

Nope…

I had a friend post and delete.

5 Likes

Epic Brown Adventure Board Task

Dec. 27, 2019 | Day 116 since first Deeds in AB:


Without Epic Tasks

Non-Flash Offer Table

Deed Type Current Amt Total Amt Days Needed To Complete
Imperial 19 102 623
Blue 30 146 565
Green 38 146 446
Red 43 176 475
Yellow 28 176 730
Purple 22 176 928
Brown 28 176 730

With Flash Offer Table

Deed Type Current Amt Total Amt Days Needed To Complete Price [USD]
Purple 30 176 681 $17.00
Green 40 146 424 $1.99

With Epic Tasks

Non-Flash Offer Table

Deed Type Current Amt Total Amt Days Needed To Complete
Imperial 19 102 623
Blue 32 146 530
Green 40 146 424
Red 45 176 454
Yellow 30 176 681
Purple 24 176 851
Brown 30 176 681

With Flash Offer Table

Deed Type Current Amt Total Amt Days Needed To Complete Price [USD]
Purple 32 176 638 $17.00
Green 42 146 404 $1.99

NOTES:
These tables do not include the original freebie deeds given out by mail when deeds were introduced.
Epic Tasks provide 1 deed per color.


Writs

Writs from AB Only

Amt Color Deed Exchange Imperial Deed Exchange
20 0 0

Writs from AB and Tasks

Amt Color Deed Exchange Imperial Deed Exchange
378 3 0

NOTES:
These tables do not include the original freebie writs given out by mail as a gift.
Epic Tasks provide 179 writs.

2 Likes

Haven’t posted it on the forums yet, but I’ve come to realize deeds from Epic Tasks and all Writs are still mostly worthless to me as you’re still gated by Imperial Deeds for 50% faction treasure hoard and +1 stat. Imperial Deeds aren’t really feasible to craft with Writs so you’re still gated by the Adventure Board being “generous” enough to give you Legendary/Mythic Deed tasks.

You could essentially get enough deeds from epic tasks in time to get 25% stats for each new faction event. All I can say to that is… 25%? eh? I guess.

4 Likes

623 days to complete Imperial deed rate. I’m going to bookmark and mute this thread. I’ll check back in once I’ve completed all kingdoms to 15, and see how much longer it took me. Thanks for tracking this. Cheers.

3 Likes

Writ Update

Without Epic Tasks

Without Flash Offer

Amt Color Deed Exchange Imperial Deed Exchange
20 0 0

With Flash Offer

Amt Color Deed Exchange Imperial Deed Exchange
1020 10 1

With Epic Tasks

Without Flash Offer

Amt Color Deed Exchange Imperial Deed Exchange
378 3 0

With Flash Offer

Amt Color Deed Exchange Imperial Deed Exchange
1378 13 1
3 Likes

The worst part is due to their greed regarding gem currency, they are missing out on the potential boon from the path to glory. If the legendary or mythic were guaranteed new, people would buy them in advance for both the exclusive period with a new mythic, or even when a new legendary hits but there were 4 other legendaries diluting the pool.

They are ignoring a prize winning cash cow to beat their horse that has been dead for do long, it’s just a skeleton.

2 Likes

Let’s use today’s flash offer as an illustrative point.

Today’s offer is 750 Gems + 1000 Writs for $25 USD.

The closest gem package in the shop is 650 Gems at $50 USD, which is also 750 Gems at the Motherlode’s ($100 USD) gem purchase rate at base prices. So, at $25 USD, one could view the gems at being offered at a upwards of a 50% discount.

Also, the trend over time has been to offer a sweetener to each flash offer in the form of some in-game item of a “comparable value”. In this case, the 1000 Writs (convertable to 10 colored deeds or 1 imperial deed) are also being valued at $25 USD. Note, that this is a good benchmark as reference that an imperial deed has a base monetary value of $25 USD. The logic also holds for the Orb of Power and Medal of Nysha being valued at $50 USD, as well as other items being offered on flash offers…

This was something that I brought up during the last beta, as I needed Salty to explain to me the incentive being offered to players on each flash offer to make the connection. Perhaps this might be a good point to ping @Saltypatra on this for something that might be put on their whiteboard for review for a future update to better communicate the value proposition to players on various flash offers.

3 Likes

I really appreciate that these premium resources (deeds and medals) are being bundled with large numbers of gems for a high price. If you could buy them individually for $2-$5 each, the game would feel much more pay to win. This pricing means that I feel no pressure to buy them.

I think that might sound sarcastic, but I genuinely appreciate the design. If they have to monetize it, this is a good way to do that.

I agree that most players won’t notice the gems and will think “$25 for one deed? lolno.” The gem deal isn’t highlighted well. It should read something like “BONUS: 1000 ‘free’ writs!”

1 Like

I can say with very safe certainty that this will never happen, at least not at the prices currently being offered for Path of Glory I/II. The reason for this is analogous to the trend in packaged PC/Console games over time shifting from the Full Game + Expansion Pack model to the modern Base Game + DLC/Microtransaction model.

Via Path for Glory II, a random mythic is valued at $50 USD. If that was allowed to be a guaranteed specific monthly mythic, issues occur from a business perspective happens.

It cuts off potential revenues from the devs. A guaranteed new-release mythic offers flat, binary revenues to the devs. Either players purchase the offer or they don’t. This guaranteed offer doesn’t necessarily stop players from purchasing gems to chase that mythic, as normal, but it does create a spending ceiling. After all, why purchase more gems than what is needed for guarantee? Nevertheless, it is reasonable to say that a portion of the player base would definitely purchase this.

However, I would relatively safely assert (although such information is among the most confidential and privileged information that the devs possess and will never, ever, be made public in any way) that among the portion of the playerbase that purchases gems to chase a specific mythic, that a significant number of them purchase more than $50 USD in Gems when chasing that mythic. If the mythic is guaranteed, than any revenues earned over the $50 USD guaranteed would be lost because the guaranteed would be the better purchasing option.

Broadly speaking about gacha games in general, when a guaranteed top-tier card/unit/whatever is offered as a direct sale, it is priced at a level that is above that of which players who spend to chase that unit would normally spend. If I had to take a wild barely-educated guess at the pricing of a guaranteed specific mythic (especially it was meta-defining), and that only a single copy is ever needed by a player, I would probably place the floor at least $100 USD.

Revisiting a thread didn’t get to post on last week regarding writ to deed costs, this pricing premium for a crafting a specific player-selected deed of choice is visible there. The devs have placed a significant price premium on the player being able to craft deeds of the color of their choice. Hence the steep writ → deed conversion rate and the poor drop rate of writs on the Writing Writs I adventure board task.

That said, the very steep pricing for a presented $100+ USD specific mythic would be very poor optics for the game, and would likely never occur.

If we’re talking about money here in a pure vacuum, and ignoring all other related issues, I’d argue the opposite. The devs are chasing the cash cow that they would be ignoring if they offered guaranteed pricing to players and have the data (that we’ll never see) that backs up their design decisions.

1 Like