I’d say Gargantaur is obviously the worst because it is unlikely that we’ll ever get a situation where he can be “good”, but a strong argument can be made for a few of these in their current states.
I went with Valdis as I would never want to use her. She is bad at being a counter, her damage is low and if it were skulls not doomskulls, it would be way better.
Gargle, I actually had fun during grosh nak invasion and has kingdom/race synergy. I could put him on a team that deals with sacrifice & resurrection to see some gain. Valdis fits on team where arguably the new mythic is better just for his third trait. Another troop she was made to counter, counters her with his trait. If that doesn’t say how useless she is, I don’t know what does.
Although I’m on console, I think Gargantuar is the worst since I can hardly build a half-decent team with him, he’s so lame he makes War look good in comparison. Doomclaw is also my pick for the worst because he’s pretty much a crappier version of Kerberos, the only good thing about him is his 3rd trait.
I voted for Stonehammer.
Maybe he’s not technically “the worst” mythic, but he always manages to disappoint.
When I’m putting together a team, I sometimes think he might be a good choice, but inevitably I realize there is a better option. I found that to be true even when limited only to dwarfs.
War is pretty good IMO. Great for mopping up after e.g. weaver casts, and lots of ways to boost his attack. I also like him in place of Siren in the classic goblin team
Legit, he’s just extremely niche. Too many want to try to put him in an all Dwarves team which is a terrible idea. But there are a couple matchups where he’s a good choice. Unlike some of the other mythics who are never a good choice.
“Only dwarves” is exactly when you don’t want Stonehammer is the problem, but too many have blinders on and try to force him into the Dwarves team where he makes things worse. There have been occasions in certain matchups where he’s actually a good choice (like vs +9 Guardian Crown) as long as you build the rest of the team in non-dwarves that don’t clash with his colors.