Your long post in the other thread is what made me think about how to overcome these problems. Before the patch I definitely expected Ranking Points to play a bigger Role in the new System, but you are right - it would not work as it is now. I do believe that there would be ways to make it work though. For example (maybe?) the way I described above.
I also want to make sure to say that I love the new PVP. It feels so much better than it was before, at least for me.
This sounds very cool, and something typically associated with āGuild Warsā in mobile games. I suspect this will be part of one of the two Guild-focused updates.