I won 10 battles, but no trophy. I restarted the game already.
Anyone have the same problem?
3 Likes
Yup, stuck at 60% progress on xbox. Maybe the gate/citadel wins didn’t counted for some reason, but that’s just a wild guess.
1 Like
The same. Steam’s counter stucked at 6/10
Yes, I had 50% progress on it after 5 wins. 60% after 10 wins 
2 Likes
Can’t see my progress but I won 10 battles and don’t have it. Looking at playstation trophy details, it shows that 0.2% of players have earned it, which suggests that someone might have got lucky, but most players are not getting it, so far.
2 Likes
Didn’t pop on playstation for me. Checked all the results screens that might prompt a completion check from the game.
6/10 sad story
1 Like
Didn’t get it after 10 wins, 2 times to the Palace (PS5). I heard someone who did get it only fought the gate. Rewarded for playing poorly, another win for the devs …
2 Likes
I was at 10% yesterday after 5 wins. up to 60% today. (xbox)
1 Like
10th victory today for me, didn’t get it. I advanced further each battle. A guildie got it, who played the same battle over and over again (the “gates”). This was on PlayStation.
1 Like
At 60% too after 10 wins on Xbox. 1377 and 1399 points, since I moved on after every battle. Should I stop at the gate tomorrow? @Jeto
1 Like
Same here. Got my 5 wins yesterday and today, with after each win progressing onto the next battle. And the tracker is stuck at 60%.
Guess I’ll try again tomorrow and just fight the Keep 5 times.
Honestly, just stop adding achievements to this game already. Instead of adding more achievements that don’t unlock properly, go back and fix the achievements that Xbox and TrueAchievements show as unobtainable.
2 Likes
I’d love this too, but they are absolutely not on our side. The enjoyment or satisfaction of their players is the last thing on their mind when designing achievements. (Or when designing pretty much anything, really.)
Witness the likes of Horde Mimic, “Try this one Geoff,” 50k renown, shiny troop collection, and immortal achievements. To say nothing of the stuff they’ve left broken and unobtainable for years.
The only use these devs have for the achievement/trophy system is twisting the arm of completionists to punish them through excruciating grinds.
Not long ago I was thumbing through an achievement/trophy hunter’s forum for a completely unrelated game, in a thread of complaints over how terrible they had made its achievement list, when I ran across a post saying something like “Hey, just be glad it’s not as awful as Gems of War. If finishing an achievement list is something you care about, never ever start that game.”
I surprised myself with just how bitter a laugh escaped me.
2 Likes
The solution is to enter guild wars from the pvp screen. I did 1 battle today and it popped. Or it could be that it pops after the 11th battle regardless.
2 Likes
90% after 10 wins so hopefully pick it up today. For just once id like to see an update that hasn’t got a litany of bugs attached
2 Likes
I think it only checks/updates the tracker when you win the gate battle specifically.
That would explain why everyone was stuck at 60% (win #6 at the start of day 2), and people who gate camped unlocked it without issue.
It just popped for me when clearing the gate (win 11) at the start of day 3.
7 Likes
mine stayed stuck at 60% through my 5 wins today, popped 5-10 minute after finishing them.
I think it’s any battle with the Guardian Sentinel team, so undefended buildings count too. Explains why I had 50% after day 1. Our opponents had set no defences.
2 Likes
I entered through the guild menu, just to check. Trophy popped after gate battle. So the PvP menu theory seems busted.
Still seems the best theory we have, so far.