Thanks. It is good that A and B fighting each other.
Sorry there’s a lot of info here and I skimmed through it, but didn’t see any mention of this.
All of the various Keeps ‘troop type’ restrictions seem to be the same this month as they were last month. I don’t see anything about the types rotating or changing from month to month either.
There’s already a clear meta Keep that’s going to be the choice for every guilds defense because the troop types are very, very good compared to other Keeps.
Can’t wait to fight the same defense Keeps every match up every month.
2 Likes
And that is?
2 Likes
this 27/30 defenders thing in 2 days thing at this point of the game’s life is rather rough.. Definitely wish we had more time..
2 Likes
You need to understand the game is very complicated. There is a lot of different events and each event are different.
GW isn’t an exception, this new GW is complicated.
Choose the keeper, place defences (isn’t really handy this part) for 3 days of fight.
Everything in daily, really you are not helping/listen players.
The players left the game because you build the new gw on the moon (travelling there take time), there didn’t come back for this crap
It’s a bloody work to explain at everyone how the gw work with this short time line.
It’s like the players come in the game and with they download the game they download the knowledge. Just for you know isn’t that.
Of course, a lot of bugs doesn’t help, what is nice you keep the update in gw week (sarcasm)
4 Likes
Ya this isn’t working. It doesn’t matter how many times we ask the guild to set a defense in chat or discord there are always 4-6 members who never look at either in those 48 hours we have to set them.
4 Likes
Should be the nembers of the guild who choose 3 different defences per area than 27 players set the own defences.
The troops’ stats could be calculated by the lvl of the guild
Was hoping with the feedback and update, we wouldn’t still be so blind as to what’s going on in Guild Wars.
Still no idea which of our members have even played, never mind their wins, losses or score. Also no clue how my own defence is doing.
6 Likes
Given the score bonus for “sets”, I’m ok with not seeing an individual score tally as there will be times where the best move for the guild won’t necessarily be the same as the best move for the individual.
The rest is 100% spot on and I would file it more under a general lack of feedback. The game isn’t really offering any feedback to measure the amounts of effort we put in.
Matchmaking system needs an improvement, todays battle for my guild is completely one-sided (rank 8 vs rank 231), guidlies are discouraged, doing only gate battles to keep personal rewards at least. Would be nice to have an opponent closer to our level, to play battles, that have a significance.
3 Likes
Restrict Chrysantherax in PvP Defence!!!
3 Likes
Yeah. I have lost the palace battle to a Chrysanterax team. An unlucky starting board, a lucky reprechaun cast… and everything is wiped out.
But there’s a silver lining: I won’t buy a GW pass due to this loss
3 Likes
I’m against replacing troops but with how stupid the restrictions they set up where your best troop does 54 damage to all and there’s 162 3x the amount and fills itself back up is ridiculous.
Chrsantherax is not the problem the developers are problem
GW’S should have stayed the way it was before this debacle they created
3 Likes
I’m in the number 1 guild playing against a guild l have never heard of been playing 10 years every battle is a gate battle which is completely boring nothing competitive about it
Why would they even want to attack us beyond the gate ? Has to be just as frustrating for them as it is for us
3 Likes
“Once a new Guild War day begins, your Guild will be assigned an opponent – reasonably close in ranking to your own Guild.”
@Jeto - can you let us know what the Devs consider to be “reasonably close” ? Today we’re playing a guild that is 27 spots higher than us. My thinking on reasonably close is more like 10-15 spots above and below.
TIA
6 Likes
May be some hidden math, may be previous war results are taken into the account, today for us it is 231 vs 91, better then yesterday, but still quite one-sided
Please look into this, Rob text that they had the same non active opponent today
Same guild dead guild 3 days in a row now 
1 Like
I imagine they can reimagine to get things right for once.
1 Like
Na rasslabone used to be a B1 veteran. Participating in GWs was the core idea of our guild and it is almost the only thing that holds us together.
And then we get this. Our enemy hasn’t set any defences and hasn’t attacked. (OK, it gives us easy 50 gold marks but it doesn’t give us a challenge or a feeling of excitement.)
I’m wondering if there was a bug and we faced a guild that hadn’t signed up for the GWs.
2 Likes