Both the scores and the names of the guilds my guild was shown to be fighting on the day of battle were different than what was reported next day. With a Stat report generated 30 minutes after rollover totally at odds with one that was reported to a different guildmate 6.5 hours after rollover. Who knows what’s accurate then? Should have been fixed by now.
And I need to be able to see all player stats, wins/losses, total played for guild leader purposes as well. please.
Very frustrating to see zero meaningful updates since last GW. How about some responsiveness to player feedback and transparency to dev priorities?
I’ve invested significant funds and more substantial time to this game. No more $$$ until/unless there are meaningful updates and getting close to a prohibitive level of frustration with the game.
Hello Jeto and the entire community,
I’m extremely disappointed with this Guild Wars! Not only did we face either a dead guild or a guild created by the Devs… It was absolutely BAD ! Where’s the fun and challenge in playing like this?? Furthermore, we can’t buy the Guild Wars Medallion, and we also have a Crash Game bug when viewing the Guild’s activity!
I can feel the end of the game coming; the Devs aren’t doing much anymore!
As they say: Every beginning must come to an end!
Update. Our guild actually likes the new guild wars better. We are Level 14 on regular god level leaderboard. We have players from level 1000 to 1947. Players that are at lower levels are struggling but can play the gate, paragons can play to the palace. This allows more freedom to play where you are able. At first we weren’t sure if we wanted to opt out, but decided the rewards were worth it. However, we were disappointed when we could not buy the medallion during this event. That might change whether we decide to opt in in the future.
Was the medallion a bug, or was it locked on purpose? If it was on purpose we might not play future events.
~pro tem guild leader, Mana Bombers
Please do not post bug reports in to this thread.
If you have a bug, that does not already have a bug report thread, please create one. So it is not mixed in with feedback here.
Also, I understand the frustrations, but while I’m trying to gather feedback, it will make it a lot easier if I am also not filtering out (valid) complaints about the game, the game modes etc.
Feedback: forcing us to use the restricted team (as opposed to encouraging us via bonus points, like in the previous GW) is universally hated by our guildies.
E.g. they are forced to either avoid fighting severely unbalanced battles such as the Palace (and thus feel like they are letting the guild down) or risk losing battles, therefore losing their individual bonus track rewards for the week.
I did not use a mythic on my attack team and went 20-0. I fought the teams you mentioned. You should have had an immortal to use. Went with Centuragon, Broken Star (Exploder and Summons), Immortal Sagirrarian, and Astral Spirit with Elamentalist. The goal was to use get Immortal Sagirrarian up for True Damage the strongest enemy. Pretty simple if you know when to use each troop.
The PvP icons should be removed from the rewards especially if the event is in the last week of a PvP season. Or these ones should be allowed to roll over and give full value. Currently they are pretty pointless.
Our guild has already participated in the first Guild War!
However, we still haven’t received a ranking to date!! When will that happen?
So is this a bug or not?
Everything that was wrong with it the first time is still wrong with it now.
Maybe lets start with a scoreboard?
Saludos!? Un par de recomendaciones.
1° Por favor evitamos luchar siempre en la misma puerta de entrada.
Una vez ganada la batalla estaría bien ,como antiguamente no volver a pelear con el mismo enemigo y avanzar .
Evitamos a los jugadores que sólo luchan batallas fáciles para conseguir las recompensa y evitamos también por error luchar 2 veces en la misma sala.
Gracias.
No sé si alguien más ha comentado esto pero no pude leerlo todos los mensajes.
Of all the troop types you had to choose!!!
in-game Guild Wars:
Upcoming Restrictions: Dwarf
well, we have 24 days to figure it out
@devs. You need to listen to your community. Stop guild wars. It doesn’t work in its current state. Do the work to fix the bugs BEFORE you bring it back again. You are killing your game and your reputation. PLEASE listen to us. Don’t bring it back in June. Take the time to read the feedback. Fix the problems and then test it before re releasing it
And that was “New and improved GW” round#2. As a short recap: Old, good working GW was canceled over a year ago to “improve things”. When it came back, it was already way more flawed then the old version. I pointed out several things there which needed improvement then, and for whatever reason, April GW was cancelled and GW delayed to end of May which we just had. While apparently nothing had changed, and the leaderboard pairing just showed it does not properly work. Something we also already had last time, but it was brushed under the rug because “no scores to actually form a leaderboard yet”.
Quite frankly, I don’t understand why you don’t get your act together here. You HAD it working for years before you took it down to “improve it”. You worked on this “reimagined GW” for a year, and just took the needed stuff out to add the pathing roads and dumbed down defense system, while at the same time clamping the Attack teams down to one kingdom. Kingdoms, which vary hard in their usefulness. Like first time we would get Mist of Scales or Nexus, the attack teams will look like powerlevel 9000 compared to what we could use so far. Anyway, here I go again since apparently last time nobody gave a fuck.
Jeto’s management, especially forgot to tell him to send us as a priority this Monday morning their most sincere apologies for this huge GW joke, for this multitude of bugs, for all responses to players on these 4 days of catastrophic GW, we had last night, one of the two posts closed explaining to us that we should not talk about bugs in the conversation, and in the other conversation we are just told that it is a visual bug, we are really taken for donkeys, it is also a visual bug to meet the same guild 3 days in a row and to lose 3 days in a row??? it is also a visual bug to be massacred by the 4th guild in the world??? (only 4 players from our country were able to beat the palace out of 30 players, congratulations to our opponents), please ask your management if this is their idea of an Event where we should have fun and not be disgusted by what we experienced over 4 days, it is true that I do not live in Australia, so the customs of politeness are perhaps not the same in your country as in the rest of the world, I will go and find out on the Internet if in Australia the word “apologies” exists in your country or not. Jeto each time I specify “your management” because I know that you are only relaying and that you only have the right to publish the comments and information that you have been authorized to do. We are also waiting this week for the compensation in gold marks for this GW if your management has not forgotten that we are the customers and that it is our daily purchases that pay for everyone’s monthly salaries by continuing to keep your game alive, a game that we still appreciate so much, so I don’t mind spending with you as long as we are respected as customers. Best regards
Which is entirely correct. There’s also some precious jewelry in a safe on the Titanic, it might just take a little bit of effort to retrieve it.
News flash, less than 1% of the player base owns it. Which is everybody who paid for it, plus a lucky few who won the jackpot. These number will change over the next months, when it no longer matters.
That’s actually a bad result for being part of the privileged F2P stomper group. Cattauri King was such a Free Win button, I wonder how they are intending to top this for the next GW to increase sales.
Well…we do get dwarves, but I don’t think it will be so bad. And I honestly meant that as a joke, and I had no intention of ruining our next Guild War experience.
Apothecary will be MVP, and if we get to choose any weapon, we will have plenty of options to lay waste to our opponents. Stone hammer is a great tank that can stun opponents, we have a 50% mana start troop that most people should have by now, plus plenty of other options. Biggest problem will be the damage, but our hero can solve that problem pretty easily.
“If more people valued home above gold… this world would be a merrier… place.”–Thorin Oakenshield
I wouldn’t jump to the conclusion that it’s due to trolling.
They could just be selfish, because the personal GW reward track is at odds with the guild goal. If you’re only at 13/18 wins on Day 3, you have to choose between guaranteed wins to get all personal rewards, or fighting for guild victory of some extra marks.
They really should change the requirements for the personal rewards.
Might be. But we jumped from 33-36 at Gate suddenly to over 40 on the last day. Feels a bit like after three days complaining they should not attack the Gate five times, a few candidates just went the “Oh yeah? Up yours!” road.
In the end, they would gain MORE rewards, if we would actually win the day over “pathing bonus”. Attacking 5x the Gate is 500 points and brings nothing for the Path-progress to benefit the Guild. And while I had a bad day myself and played 3/2 in a green kingdom (the joy of walking Elemental → Divine path), I made 502 points doing so while at least trying to help the Guild with the pathing-progress by choosing the most difficult route so maybe a weaker player could walk the easier way and level the buildings up along there.
At this point it also does not matter so much if some people do it intentional to spite the ones who take GW more serious, or if they are just lazy and do the absolute minimum and don’t understand a single word when you broadly explain things ingame or over discord. The main problem here is we can not see Who does What. They can hide in anonymity and the Guild leadership does not know who either talk to, to play things right, or just kick out and replace with someone more willing to actually play for the greater good. We just need some internal tracking to see whats up with the players. In an ideal version we might be able to track which path everyone choose to fight. But in the most basic way, a scoreboard to see how many points someone scored with what fights (like in the old days) would already be sufficient. 5/0 and 500 points total? Yeah, there is one of the lazy Gate bums. 4/1 800 points? Someone seemingly failed on the way to palace or at palace fight, but walked up to the inner defense at least and leveled the buildings along the way. Right now we see nothing. And that situation needs to be fixed. Best two Guild Wars ago -,-
On console, let the cursor move freely around the guild-keep screen and “snap” to the nearest building, like the way the cursor moves on the world map. The cursor movement as it is is wildly unintuitive.
Granted, this is hardly the worst of New Guild Wars’ problems, but it seems like it’d be a fairly simple change. The behavior already exists elsewhere in the game.
