If a member is leaving your guild after ToD to join another guild. The member made Requirements, and your guild is going to finish in the top 10. Do you let that member stay until after reset to get the rewards they helped earn?
Or
Do you just suck?
1 Like
I donât get why you posted this?? Sounds like a problem for the guild and people in question. Donât see how posting here is going to help ya.
1 Like
To hear from other managers to understand if Iâm alone in thinking people should get the rewards they earned. Regardless of whether they intend to leave the guild or notâŚ
1 Like
Iâd let them collect. It was a courtesy just to give the heads up for intent to leaveâwhich allows you to recruit and have a replacement ready to go, rather than just a surprise empty spot on Monday.
9 Likes
Exactly. And if people get punished for doing the right thing, theyâll stop doing the right thing. So another reason to post this topic isâŚ
A clear message to those GM who donât let players get the rewards. The player did the right thing. By you choosing to do the wrong thing only hurts the community.
This is (at least) the second time the guild who inspired this post has partook in such shannigans. So if I was in that guildâŚI wouldnât tell the GM of my intentions.
1 Like
The family of guilds I belong to have always let people who notify us theyâre leaving stay to collect the rewards they helped the guild earned - for every event including GW. Weâve never had an issue with a replacement not being willing to wait until after weekly reset to join us either as long as itâs clear to them they have the spot and the reason for the wait.
I felt bad for one of our most recent recruits who had a similar issue happen to them GW week and was happy for them when the person leaving up & left before reset so he was able to collect our rewards since he couldnât get his own.
That is a pretty crappy way to treat someoneâŚ
2 Likes
I agree that they should be allowed to collect their rewards. But the GM who will boot somebody beforehand is not a GM who will give a damn about your opinion.
5 Likes
I say let them stay and collect the rewards. The rewards ainât nothing too be impressed with on TOD thou. But thatâs the right thing to do.
So what do u guys do in GW Week?
When U know some how someone on youâre Guild is gonna mess it up for the rest.
Do u 1 kick. so u have time too recruit?
Or 2. Take the chance and hoping they do their part?
1 Like
It has occurred to me that someone got booted from your guild during the last iteration of ToD - but I guess thereâs always a good reason when youâre the one doing the booting. 
1 Like
True or false I donât care any drama is worth watching 
Personally I donât care about gm or no gm. You canât be a gm without the rest of the guild. And what does a gm do extra apart from recruiting 
personally in game where the rewards are based on RNG I only care about myself if the guild or the gm is poo and lazy then I leave without notice on Monday straight after collecting my rewards. Kicking someone from guild before collecting rewards when they are clearly not freeloaders make you look like you need to put everything down and and go outside and get some fresh air and reconnect with reality. Most your guildys came from a guild that don requires gold in which they had a chance to lvl their kingdoms before moving to higher bracket guild without notifying anyone. At the end of the day this just a game in 5-10years we wonât even remember each other not sure why care now 
See, buddy, youâre asking a subjective question, so you canât just tack on âyouâre wrong if you do thisâ.
The answer is âyou do whatever you wantâ. One is nicer to the person who did some work for you. One isnât. One tells people who join your guild you care about helping them feel rewarded. The other tells people youâre more interested in âgetting backâ people who leave for whatever reason (most likely âfragile egoâ).
Just like people will pee in a bottle and eat one meal a day to keep a job, some people will put up with anything to be in a prestigious guild. Others hear stories like this and stay the hell away. Itâs not like there arenât 59 other very high-ranked guilds.
So now you contemplate if you make an aloof, casual reply to pretend like you were joking in the first post and that itâs DEFINITELY not the case youâd let a member meet your requirements without giving them the rewards out of a sense of revenge.
and
People think you suck.
No âorâ. You canât shake the devilâs hand then say youâre only kidding.
Discord is a Requirement in AWR. So someone leaving the guild server is not making Requirements. 
A literal 
ton if they are a great GM.
1 Like
Thatâs a great question for a different thread.
Enlighten me please. From my experience and I am in top 10 guild I donât see anything gm do thatâs extra apart from recruiting in which most guildys do it. Advice on what troops to use is all over global most people that scout Dooms are not GM and i havenât met anyone in top 100 that needed to be managed yet . I totally understand the effort and the pride any GM had to go thru to reach where they at atm and the frustration of loyalty but at the end of the day everyone looks for their own interests including you and me
Donât assume so much. If you arenât a GM then you have no clue what itâs like to be a GM. Otherwise, I decline to list the things that I do besides âRecruitâ.
1 Like
Darn it! I knew there was a catch-22 somewhere! 
1 Like
Oh so it sounds like you didnât include all of the information in the first post. The OP made it sound like they met requirements. I have a lot less sympathy for someone who didnât, and I actually do consider âbe part of Discordâ a more important requirement than some of the in-game ones.
But why ask a question about a scenario if youâre not going to show all the information? The situation now is completely different than it was in OP, even if (as it seems) you were being tongue-in-cheek about the Discord requirement.
Or you could just not assume to know more than you actually know.
And go by literally was written in the OP.
Considering the forums are pretty strict about call out posts. So I gave as much detail as I could. But what else could possibly matter?
Itâs wrong to kick people who earned rewards before they were Rewarded to them.
They are only able to kick them because the player is corteous enough to give the GM a heads up about leaving.
TL:DRâŚI donât like it when players are punished for doing the right thing. No more details require than that. 