I wondered if people would struggle with this when I first saw them because – unlike the gems themselves – there’s nothing to differentiate the potions aside from the colour, so I mocked this up using Color Oracle:
Ah, I see them if I zoom way in and look for them, but I can’t otherwise see them on my android phone or my laptop. It’s super subtle.
What’s funny is that I used mspaint to get all the potions in a single screenshot, and I didn’t even notice then when zoomed in to copy/paste them.
Part of the issue, I think, is the three-quarter view angle on them. Putting the corner of the bottle right in the middle helps to obscure the element logo. Maybe if the potion bottles were spherical, like the full rejuvenation pots in Diablo II?
Really? At this point it’s clearly just wishful thinking, but the wording seemed a bit ambiguous, like you might be able to select one of the five colors. Wouldn’t be the first time something was worded in a confusing/misleading way.